A good toaster oven functions as an oven and goes beyond making a toast; it practically replaces many appliances such as an air fryer, makes it much easier to prepare a dish like bagels, chicken, bread, roast vegetables, and baking. It’s an essential tool in the kitchen for it preheats faster and uses minimal energy.
The versatility of these toaster ovens is hard to beat, for they can make life easier for you. However, based on the functionality and usage of various toaster ovens from different brands, we can develop the top 7 of the best toaster oven America’s Test kitchen. But which toaster oven is the best? Then you should pick from one of our reviews below.
A toaster oven is an appliance that can efficiently and quickly prepare a wide variety of foods; it reheats, bakes, broils, toasts, browns, and defrosts a small quantity of foods.
Built with a fast-heating element that helps cooks food faster, a toaster oven is one of the most versatile additions you should have to your kitchen. Thus, a toaster oven can cook like an oven but in a shorter amount of time, but it does not have the quick cooking time as a microwave. Nevertheless, it can accomplish various cooking modes for different foods using less energy than a full-sized regular oven.
Reviews of the Top 7 Best Toaster Oven America’s Test Kitchen
Here are top rated toaster oven to buy in 2021
Top 1- Breville BOV800XL Smart Oven
Breville BOV800XL toaster oven is one of the best in American’s test kitchen with a unique heat system. It is an intelligent oven convection-powered toaster oven that helps speed up cooking time by replacing the cold air in the oven with heated air; this convection reduces the cooking time by 30%. Thus, it has an independent element IQ with nine cooking functions: Toast, Bake, Bagel, Roast, Broil, Pizza, Cookies, Warm, and Reheat.
Breville BOV800XL Oven has a large capacity wide enough to take six slices simultaneously, making cooking easier and faster. Thus it has an LCD light which indicates the cooking time for precise cooking. However, the accessories of the toaster oven are also non-stick, making it dishwasher safe.
- Sleek design
- Nine pre-set cooking functions
- Non-sticky coating
- 1800W power.
- LCD light for precise cooking
- Easy to clean
- A bit expensive
- It takes lots of counter space
Top 2- Cuisinart TOB-260N1 Chef’s Convection Toaster Oven
This versatile convection toaster oven has 15 cooking options; it provides a sufficient capacity for your slice and will hold up to 13 inches of pizza; it is one of the best time-saving and energy-efficient toaster ovens. With this toaster oven, you can combine any two cooking functions or temperatures and run them simultaneously, that is, toast and broil at the same time. Cuisinart TOB-260N1 Convection Toaster Oven has a classic design, and all the materials are BPA-free.
Nevertheless, the LED light displays the function, time, temperature, and toast shade in use and helps keep track of the hour for precise cooking even when plugged out. The ‘Always Even’ toast shade control function ensures that you get exact results with the required shade. Thus, the oven provides you with four different rack positions with a convenient slide-out rack made from a non-stick coating that is easy to clean.
- Spacious interior
- 15 cooking functions
- Slide out rack
- Exact heat sensor
- 1800 watt power
- BPA-Free accessories
- Buttons are fragile
- Not suitable for air frying
- Oven door doesn’t close with time
Top 3- Panasonic FlashXpress Compact Toaster Oven
This toaster oven is more expensive than Cuisinart and Breville; it is a compact, easy-to-use toaster oven with a design that fits any kitchen. Panasonic FlashXpress Compact Toaster Oven has a double infrared heating efficiency; there’s no need for preheating for the ceramic infrared heating elements are positioned in the front and back to toast, bake, brown, and reheat the food evenly. It has six pre-set cooking options and a simple touch-button sensor for manual temperature settings.
Thus, G110P-K has a see-through glass door that enables one to see the meal’s processing, and an electronic alarm makes a notification when the food is ready. It has a square-shaped inner tray suitable for pizza up to 9 inches, and the crumb tray is detachable for easy cleaning.
- Pre-set button controls are easy to use
- Radiates little heat into the kitchen
- Cooks and toast evenly
- 1300 watt
- Detachable crumb tray
- The power button tends to fail after some time of use.
Top 4- Breville BOV900BSS Smart Oven
Breville BOV900BSS smart oven is the most expensive and one of the best ovens that Breville makes, designed with 2-speed convection fans for efficient cooking, a regular fan, and a super fan. This toaster oven has adjustable Element IQ, which ensures the heat is distributed evenly in the range for the best crisp. With this smart toaster oven, you can prepare your favourite within just a few minutes; it can roast up to 9 slices simultaneously, for the interior is spacious.
It has 13 preset cooking functions: Baking, Roasting, Broiling, Toasting, Bagel, Warming, Pizza, Proof, Air Frying, Cookies, Slow Cook, Dehydrate, and Reheat. Based on the function chosen, each element is turned on or off at lower or higher power by the automatic smart IQ. The LCD indicates the mode selected, and the LED light automatically turns on if done toasting.
- The interior is spacious
- 13 preset cooking functions
- 1800W power.
- Preheats faster than an oven
- Adjustable element IQ
- The oven is a bit heavier
- The door doesn’t shut tightly over time
Top 5- Oster Toaster Oven-Digital Convection Oven
Convection Toaster Oven is also one of the best convection ovens in American’s test kitchen; it cooks faster, evenly, and gives the food a crispier result. It can hold six slices of bread and fit a large pizza in for toasting without any difficulty. The Oster Toaster Oven has a countertop design with seven pre-set functions, and it doesn’t consume much energy.
Fortunately, this toaster oven comes with the latest convection technology from Oster, and it’s effortless to operate. It has a LED interior light for easy viewing during the cooking process. It comes with accessories like a durable baking pan and detachable crumb tray, easy to clean after use.
- Large interior
- Seven cooking settings
- LED interior light and digital control
- Removable crumb tray
- 1300 watt power
- Easy cleanup
- Has no recipe or baking charts
- Slow toasting
Top 6- Black+Decker TO1313SBD Toaster Oven
Black & Decker TO1313SBD is a four-slice compact, versatile toaster oven with four cooking functions; baking, toasting, broiling and keeping food warm. It comes with a baking pan and a broiler pan that fits perfectly into the small toaster oven interior and ensures optimum heat distribution for an even toast. It perfectly fits for a countertop in the kitchen, and it is one of the best performers in American’s test kitchen.
However, this toaster oven comes with a durable glass window that allows users to see what’s happening in the oven while the food is in process. Black+Decker TO1313SBD has a 30-minute timer for precise cooking and a detachable crumb tray that is dishwasher safe.
- It has four cooking functions
- Toast evenly
- Easy to clean
- 1200 watt
- It doesn’t have a convention fan
Top 7- COMFEE’ 4-slice Toaster Oven Countertop
COMFEE 4-slice Toaster Oven is one of the best small space compact and versatile toaster ovens; it has three cooking functions: bake, broil, and toast. This toaster oven is designed to be versatile and can easily fit four slices and toast it to your preferred taste. It has a glass door where you can easily see what you are cooking and control it if there is a need.
Nevertheless, COMFEE’ Toaster Oven has a 30 minutes built-in timer for a precise browning shade and longer baking. The toaster oven is very easy to operate, it comes with non-stick accessories, and the tray is removable for easy cleaning.
- It heats up and cooks very much quickly
- Three preset functions
- Removable crumb tray
- Easy cleaning
- Non-sticky accessories
- Has a 30-minute built-in timer
- 1000 watt power
- It does not fit large size pan
The 5 Best Toaster America’s Test Kitchen Reviews in 2021
Top 1- Breville BTA730XL Stainless Steel, 4-Slice Toaster
The CS130-AO is a versatile and stress-free toaster oven that offers a wide range of different functions. It has 12 different pre-set modes, which enables you to easily adjust the setting to whatever is appropriate for the food you want to cook. COSORI CS130-AO Air Fryer acts as an oven, a toaster, an air fryer, a dehydrator, and more. A less experienced person can manage this toaster well without having the risk of burning or under-cooking, for it has a timing element.
However, in American’s test kitchen COSORI is also one of the best in terms of health benefits, for it saves 85% less fat than a regular oven. The cooking functions of the COSORI CS130-AO Air Fryer include Rotisserie, Dehydrate, Pizza, Bake, Air Fry, Toast, Bagel, Roast, Broil, Cookies, and Ferment. The CS130-AO has an interior LED light that lets the user see the meal being cooked. It comes with six accessories: a crumb tray, fry basket, food tray, wire rack, rotisserie fork set, and rotisserie handle, which are non-stick and easy to clean.
- Has a smart control
- 12 pre-set cooking functions
- 1800 watt power setting
- It has an interior led light
- Heats evenly
- Some of the pre-set tend to feel a bit gimmicky
Top 2-Cuisinart CPT-160P1 Metal Classic Toaster
This toaster oven has BPA-free plastic material and well-polished stainless steel to perfectly fit any kitchen decor. It is a 2-slice toaster from Cuisinart with three cooking modes: Bagel, Defrost, Reheat, and six preset cooking functions. It has a LED light indicator that helps see how the food is progressing while toasting, and it automatically brightens the bread that is fully baked or toasted.
Cuisinart metal classic toaster oven is the second American’s test kitchen product, which is easy to use and manage, has a detachable crumb tray that allows easy cleaning of the toaster oven. It toasts evenly and has an extra lift carriage for easy toast removal.
- Sleek design
- Led light indicator
- Slide-out crumb tray
- Durable materials
- Six preset cooking functions
- It has a convenient cord wrap
- Carriage lever which allows easy removal of toast
- It is not dishwasher safe
- No toast warning feature
Top 3- Dash DVTS501AQ mini Toaster
Among all the toaster ovens reviewed in American’s test kitchen, this 2-slice toaster oven has the most innovative design. It is designed to be extra-wide, and has seven toast settings for precise cooking. A large panel glass at the front allows you to see your bread getting darker as it cooks. The seven toast settings will enable you to toast your bread from lighter toast to a more crispy toast.
The best mini toaster oven wouldn’t take much space on your countertop; then, Dash DVTS501AQ mini toaster is a great choice. It features three one-touch buttons, which are Defrost, Reheat, and Bagel. The automatic shutoff function prevents the toaster from overheating and the toast from getting burnt. It comes with a recipe guide, controls are easy to operate, and the tray is taken out for cleanup quickly.
- Auto shutoff feature
- Easy to clean
- Seven various browning levels
- Even heating when toasting
- Takes counter space with its long width
Top 4- Hamilton Beach 22633 Extra-Wide Slot Toaster
Hamilton Beach toaster oven is one of the best toaster ovens that take a little countertop space and perfectly suit any kitchen decor. It is a compact toaster with four spacious slots to bake extra-thick slices of bagels and bread. If getting your toast done quickly is your topmost priority, then this toaster oven is for you as it is the fastest in American’s test kitchen.
This toaster oven comes with three modes which are bagel, defrost and cancel. It has a high lift feature which makes it easy to reach more miniature toast if the food gets stuck in the oven, and you can temporarily stop the toasting with the cancel button. However, the crumb tray that comes with it doesn’t slide out; you have to open it and brush off the crumbs for cleaning. The toaster oven has an auto-shutoff function that automatically shuts off to prevent burning or overheating.
- Very fast in toasting
- Three toasting modes.
- High lift feature
- Defrost and bagel settings
- Accommodates larger and thicker slice
- The crumb tray is not detachable
Top 5- AmazonBasics 3680, 2 Slice toaster
This model is the best basic toaster oven to quickly cook a set of toast or two bagel halves in the morning. It has an extra-lift lever that allows you to safely remove the slice from the toaster without burning your hands. The six shades of browning enable you to have precise cooking of your preference; it also comes with defrost and cancel buttons.
AmazonBasics 2-Slice Toaster bagel warms the outside and makes the inside of the slice crispy, and the frozen function defrosts the bread. It also has a LED indicator that allows you to see the cooking process.
- Six settings and three modes of toasting
- Extra-lift lever
- Detachable crumb tray
- Led light indicator
- · It doesn’t have a toast alarm
Defrost Cycle A defrost cycle feature is an important thing to consider when purchasing a new toaster oven for your home if you are someone who likes to store their food or bread in the freezer.
Ensure the cleanup system is swift and accessible before buying a toaster, so it is essential to get a toaster oven with a detachable tray for easy cleaning.
Most toaster ovens come with specific temperature settings. It would help if you were sure if the toaster allows you to choose the oven’s temperature before you purchase one.
Be sure to get a toaster oven with multiple functions; although toaster Ovens typically offer numerous cooking functions, you must choose the one that can give you the precise cooking you want.
The capacity and size of the toaster oven is also an essential thing to consider before purchasing one. Some toaster ovens have extra-wide slots that can hold up thicker, and longer bread without squashing the toast and also the size of the oven will fit into the countertop of your kitchen.
Choosing a toaster oven with an easy and understandable operation, easy-to-use buttons, and clear displays is always better because it is a home appliance.
The best place to put your toaster oven in the kitchen is a countertop, cabinet, or kitchen shelf.
Although both Breville and Cuisinart are great, Cuisinart is better in quality, and they are more economical to the average household.
A toaster oven lets you prepare your breakfast without delay; it is highly energy-efficient and doesn’t consume much space in the kitchen. However, The seven best toaster ovens mentioned above are picked based on numerous testing of the American’s test kitchen; they are the best functions and features.
Thank you! Northpoint Custard